Skip to content
Request a Quote
Menu
Placeholder for a photo (BH-P028-S01-I01)

When Parts Do Not Meet the Agreed Requirement

Parts are checked against what was agreed for the order: the drawing and its revision, any approved sample and the written requirements.

If delivered parts do not meet that basis, report the problem with evidence, and it is reviewed and resolved against the same basis. The clearer the requirement is before production, the easier any later question is to settle. A problem then becomes a comparison between the parts and a written reference, not a difference of opinion.

Agreed Requirement

Start with the references the parts are measured and judged against.

What the Parts Are Checked Against

A part conforms when it meets the requirement agreed for the order, not a general idea of good quality. Every requirement you rely on needs to be in one of the references below before production starts.

When two references disagree, for example the drawing and the 3D model, agree in advance which one takes priority.

ReferenceWhat it usually settles
The drawing and its revisionDimensions, tolerances, material, finish and notes
The 3D modelGeometry the drawing does not dimension, where the drawing refers to the model
An approved sampleAppearance, feel or fit that you have accepted, kept as a physical reference
Written requirements in the orderInspection scope, documents, packaging and any special checks

Before Shipment

The next question is how the parts are checked against these references before they ship.

Inspection and Records Before Shipment

Parts are inspected against the agreed requirement before they ship. Set the scope of that inspection in the order: which features are measured, on how many parts, and with what record.

A record tied to the part number and revision shows what was checked and found before shipment. If a problem is reported later, it can be compared with that record instead of starting from memory.

Agreed in the order

The features to check, the number of parts checked and the report you need with the shipment.

Checked before shipment

The parts against the drawing revision, any approved sample and the written requirements.

Kept with the order

The inspection results and the drawing revision used, so later questions can refer back to them.

Placeholder for a photo (BH-P028-S03-I01)

Report a Problem

If something still looks wrong when the parts arrive, a clear report makes it easier to review.

How to Report a Problem

Check the parts soon after they arrive, and report a problem as soon as you find it. A report made before the parts are processed further or assembled keeps the evidence clear and leaves more options open.

Keep the affected parts separate and unchanged until the review is complete. They may need to be measured again, photographed in more detail or returned before the cause is clear.

A clear report includes:

  • The order number, part number and drawing revision.
  • What is wrong, and which requirement it does not meet.
  • Photos of the problem, with the part label or packaging in view.
  • Your measurements, and the method or instrument used.
  • How many parts are affected, and how many you checked.
  • Whether the parts have been processed, assembled or used.
Placeholder for a diagram (BH-P028-S04-I01)

Resolution

Once the problem is confirmed against the agreed requirement, the remedy can be agreed.

How a Confirmed Non-Conformance Is Resolved

The report is first reviewed against the agreed requirement and the shipment records. If the parts do not conform, the remedy is agreed case by case, based on the problem, the quantity affected and what your project needs next.

The usual options are:

Rework

The affected parts are corrected, where the problem can be fixed without harming other features or the finish.

Remake

New parts are made to the agreed requirement, with the process or the checks changed where the cause calls for it.

Replacement

Conforming parts that are already available, such as spares from the same batch, are sent in place of the affected ones.

Credit

A credit or price adjustment for the affected parts, for example when you decide to use them as they are.

Costs such as return transport or sorting at your site belong to the same discussion. Agree them before any parts are sent back or reworked.

Prevent a Repeat

Putting the parts right settles this order. The next step keeps the same problem from coming back.

Preventing a Repeat

A fix for one batch does not help if the cause stays in the process. For a confirmed non-conformance, the cause is identified, a corrective action is taken and the checks are updated, so the same problem can be caught before the next shipment.

Ask for the result in writing. Many buyers use a short corrective action report, and it can follow your company's format if you have one.

Cause

What led to the problem: the reading of the drawing, the material, the process, the inspection or the packing.

Corrective action

What was changed to remove the cause, and from which order or batch the change applies.

Updated checks

How inspection was changed to catch the problem, and how the record for the next shipment shows the change.

Placeholder for a diagram (BH-P028-S06-I01)

Not Covered

Some problems fall outside this process because they were never part of the agreed requirement.

What This Does Not Cover

The process above applies to parts that do not meet the requirement agreed for the order. It does not cover:

  • Requirement changes made after the drawing, sample or order was approved.
  • Requirements that were never stated in the drawing, the sample or the order.
  • Damage caused by later processing, assembly or handling by others.
  • Use outside the conditions the part was specified for.

Changed or new requirements are handled as a new revision or a new order, with their own quotation and checks. If you are not sure whether a requirement was stated, report the problem anyway: the review starts by comparing the parts with the drawing, the sample and the order.

Questions

A few questions come up on most orders before the first shipment.

Quality Commitment Questions

What if the drawing and the approved sample disagree?

Agree which one takes priority before production and record it in the order. If that was not agreed, report the difference; the parts are then reviewed against the order and both references before any remedy is discussed.

Who decides whether parts are non-conforming?

The agreed requirement decides, not either side's opinion. Your photos and measurements, compared with the shipment records, usually settle it. Where the results differ, measure the same features again by a method both sides accept.

Do I have to send the affected parts back?

Not always. Photos and measurements may be enough, but some problems need the parts measured again or examined for the cause. Agree before returning anything, so the shipment and any costs are settled first.

Is there a deadline for reporting a problem?

Report it as soon as you find it, and before the parts are processed further. Any time limit for claims belongs in the order terms, so check them when you place the order.

Can I set my own acceptance requirements?

Yes, and the earlier the better. Send your inspection plan, report format or cosmetic standard with the enquiry, so it can be reviewed before the quotation. To talk it through first, Discuss Your Acceptance Requirements.

Discuss the Evidence Your Project Needs

Share the part drawing or description, the critical requirements and any inspection or reporting specification already in place.

Placeholder for a contact photo of Jane

Jane

BOHUI PROTOTYPES LIMITED

If a check must refer to a finished surface, assembly condition or defined test, make that context visible with the requirement. I'm your contact for starting the discussion.

For an existing order, include the order or part reference and the issue you need to review so the information can be considered in its proper context. If the concern relates to parts already received, include the order reference, affected revision, quantity and observations. Photographs and measurements help distinguish the reported issue from the original acceptance requirement without assuming a cause before review.

Jane

BOHUI PROTOTYPES LIMITED

  • Address: Xiaobian Street, Chang'an Town, Dongguan City, Guangdong Province, China

Request a Quote

Fields marked  are required.

Jane Contact Jane Privacy Policy