Skip to content
Request a Quote
Menu
Placeholder for a photo (BH-A12-S01-I01)

Die Casting vs CNC Machining for Aluminum Parts

Choose by four things: how many parts you need, how complex the shape is, whether that quantity justifies the investment in a die, and which features need machined accuracy or a particular finish.

For prototypes, small batches and designs that are still changing, CNC machining is usually the stronger candidate. For larger and repeat quantities of a stable design, especially one with thin walls and many integrated features, die casting often is. The two routes are not exclusive. Many die cast aluminum parts have their bores, sealing faces and threads machined after casting, and many die cast designs start as machined prototypes. The comparison below uses relative terms. Where the balance falls for your part depends on its geometry, alloy, finish and quantity, so ask your supplier to confirm it against your drawing.

How They Work

Start with how each route forms the part, because that explains most of the differences in cost, shape and accuracy.

How Each Route Makes the Part

CNC machining and die casting reach a similar aluminum part from opposite directions. One removes metal from a solid block; the other forces molten metal into a steel die shaped like the part.

CNC Machining

Rotating cutting tools remove material from aluminum bar, plate or block, usually a wrought alloy, until the part remains. The job needs a program and a way to hold the part, but no part-specific die, so first parts can follow soon after the design is released. Every feature must be reachable by a tool, and machine time grows with the metal removed.

Die Casting

Molten aluminum alloy is injected under high pressure into a steel die, where it solidifies quickly and is ejected. The gate, runners, overflows and flash are then trimmed off. The die has to be designed, made and trialed before production, but once it is approved, every shot repeats the same near-net shape.

Placeholder for a diagram (BH-A12-S02-I01)

Comparison

The two methods lead to different trade-offs in investment, quantity, geometry and accuracy, summarized in the table below.

Die Casting and CNC Machining Compared

Use the table as a first comparison, not a rule. Your part, alloy and quantity decide the answer.

FactorCNC machiningDie casting
Upfront investmentProgramming and fixtures; no part-specific dieA die built for the part, often with a trimming tool
QuantityOne-off parts, prototypes and smaller batchesLarger and repeat quantities, with the die cost shared across every part
GeometryAny shape a cutting tool can reach; thick and solid sections cut without difficultyThin walls, ribs and complex near-net shapes, designed with draft and even sections
Accuracy and finishClose control of machined features; visible tool marksMore variation as cast; smooth surface with parting line and ejector marks
Changes and first partsA new program; first parts without a dieDie work and new samples; first parts after the die is made and trialed

When two rows point in different directions, the expected quantity and the stability of the design usually decide.

When to Machine

Machining is the first route to consider while quantities are small or the design is still moving.

When CNC Machining Fits

Machining makes sense when a die would not pay back, or when the part needs properties a casting cannot give. With no die to spread over the order, the cost per part falls only slowly as quantity rises, but the first good part is reached with far less investment.

Machining is usually the stronger candidate when:

  • You need prototypes, pilot parts or a small batch.
  • The design is still likely to change.
  • The part needs the strength and ductility of a wrought alloy, or must be welded or heat treated.
  • Most surfaces carry close tolerances or must be flat over large areas.
  • The part needs a decorative anodized finish, which wrought alloys generally take more evenly than casting alloys.
  • The shape is mostly prismatic, with features reachable from a few directions.

Machine time, however, repeats for every part. A part cut mostly from solid, with deep pockets and thin walls, spends a long time on the machine, and as quantities grow that is often what tips the balance toward a die.

Placeholder for a photo (BH-A12-S04-I01)

When to Cast

Once the quantity can carry the cost of a die and the design has settled, die casting enters the comparison.

When Die Casting Fits

Die casting fits when the design is stable and the quantity is high enough to share the die cost across many parts. Beyond that point, each casting needs far less process time than machining the same shape from solid, and every part comes from the same die.

Larger and repeat quantities

The die is a one-time investment, so its share of each part's cost falls as more parts are cast. Repeat orders run from the same approved die.

Complex near-net shapes

Thin walls, ribs, bosses, pockets and lettering can be formed in one shot, where machining would have to remove most of a block to reach them.

Several parts in one

A casting can combine features that would otherwise be separate machined parts and fasteners, which reduces assembly work.

Then machine the features that need it. As-cast dimensions vary more than machined ones, especially across the parting line and on features formed by moving die parts. Bores, bearing seats, sealing faces, threads and precise mating faces are therefore often machined after casting. Mark them on the drawing, so the casting can be designed with machining allowance and with datums that a machining fixture can locate from.

Placeholder for a photo (BH-A12-S05-I01)

Prototype to Casting

Many cast parts begin as machined prototypes, and the step from one to the other needs planning of its own.

From Machined Prototypes to Cast Production

Machined prototypes are a sensible way to test a part that will later be die cast. They need no die and can be revised between rounds. They prove the geometry and fit, but not everything about the casting.

Plan for three differences before the die is ordered:

Design changes for casting

The production part needs draft, even walls, radii and cored-out sections that a machined prototype does not. Each change alters the geometry, so check the fit again on the revised design.

A different alloy

Die casting alloys are formulated to flow into a die and differ from the wrought grades usually machined. Strength, ductility, thermal behavior and finish response can all change, so tests that depend on them need cast parts.

Porosity and surface

Cast parts can contain small internal pores and carry parting line and ejector marks. A machined prototype shows neither, so confirm sealing and cosmetic requirements on cast samples.

Treat the first cast samples as a new validation step, and carry the critical features of the prototype drawing into the production drawing as machined features.

Placeholder for a diagram (BH-A12-S06-I01)

What to Send

Whichever route you lean toward, quotations can compare the two fairly only if both are based on the same information.

What to Send for a Route Comparison

If you are not sure which route suits, ask for both to be quoted against the same design and quantities, with tooling and part prices shown separately. Two quotations can only be compared when they price the same part in the same finished condition.

CNC machining is one of the five services Bohui produces in its own factory, and Bohui also offers aluminum and zinc alloy die casting. Send:

  • The 3D model and a drawing with critical features and tolerances marked.
  • The alloy, or the properties the part needs if no grade is fixed.
  • The first-order quantity and expected repeat or annual demand.
  • The features that must be machined, and the finish for each surface.
  • Whether the design is final or still changing.
  • Your target milestones for first parts and for production.

Discuss the Requirement with Bohui

Share the part information and the decision you need to make.

Placeholder for a contact photo of Jane

Jane

BOHUI PROTOTYPES LIMITED

I'm Jane, the contact for your enquiry.

You can also reach me by email or on WhatsApp.

Jane

BOHUI PROTOTYPES LIMITED

  • Address: Xiaobian Street, Chang'an Town, Dongguan City, Guangdong Province, China

Request a Quote

Fields marked  are required.

Jane BOHUI PROTOTYPES LIMITED Privacy Policy